Bell Hill

All Five Pirates of the Caribbean Movies Ranked From Worst to Best

‘You know what they say, one man’s treasure is another man’s trash, and when it comes to the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, opinions vary as wildly as the high seas themselves.

You’ve got five swashbuckling adventures to consider, all unique in their own ways, all carrying the distinct touch of the eccentric Captain Jack Sparrow.

Read Also  Why Does Deku Break His Bones

From the eerie charm of the Black Pearl’s curse to the dizzying whirl of stranger tides, we’ll explore each movie’s strengths and weaknesses, highs and lows, and finally, rank them from what could be considered the franchise’s bilge water to its buried treasure.

So, are you ready to set sail on this cinematic journey? It’s time to hoist the anchor and see where the wind takes us, mate.’

Key Takeaways

  • ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides’ and ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales’ are widely considered as disappointing installments, straying from the charm of the original trilogy.
  • Johnny Depp’s portrayal of Jack Sparrow in these two films is seen as a misstep, with his character being less charismatic.
  • The plots of these two films are disjointed and noisy, relying heavily on familiar characters and flashy visuals, which are perceived as cash-grab attempts.
  • ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest’ stands out as a brilliant sequel, with compelling elements such as the portrayal of Davy Jones, a memorable climax, and the addition of the ‘Curse of the Black’ subplot.

Fifth Place: On Stranger Tides


Landing in fifth place, ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides’ is widely panned as a horrifically disappointing installment in the franchise. Under Rob Marshall’s direction, the Pirates movie strays far from the charm of the original trilogy. Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow as the main lead is a misstep, resulting in a disjointed and noisy plot.

Despite these flaws, the film does have a few redeeming elements. Ian McShane’s portrayal of Blackbeard brings a menacing presence to the screen, while Penelope Cruz’s performance as Angelica adds a touch of intrigue. These characters, along with their interactions, provide some much-needed depth to an otherwise lackluster storyline.

However, these positive aspects are not enough to save the film from its overall negative reception. ‘On Stranger Tides’ fails to capture the magic and excitement that made the original trilogy so beloved by audiences. Instead, it feels like a cash grab, relying on familiar characters and flashy visuals to mask its shortcomings.

In the end, ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides’ falls short of living up to its predecessors. With a weak plot and a departure from what made the franchise successful in the first place, it is seen as a disappointment among fans and critics alike.

Fourth Rank: Dead Men Tell No Tales

3 1

Holding the fourth spot in the franchise is ‘Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales.’ Despite its attempts to revive the magic of the original, the film falls short with its less satisfying storyline and intermittent clever dialogue.

  • Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow seems less charismatic this time around.
  • Brenton Thwaites’ character feels forced and underdeveloped.
  • Javier Bardem’s villainous Salazar fails to live up to the franchise’s previous antagonists.

Middle of the Pack: At World’s End


While ‘Dead Men Tell No Tales’ may have left you wanting more, ‘At World’s End’ steps up to the plate, introducing thrilling action scenes despite its crowded character lineup and bewildering plot threads.

Under director Gore Verbinski, the introduction of Davy Jones spices up the original Black Pearl crew, with Barbossa, Elizabeth Swann, and Turner.

It may be the weakest of the first three movies, but it’s still a memorable ride.

Runner Up: Dead Man’s Chest


Diving deeper into the franchise, ‘Dead Man’s Chest’ brilliantly ups the ante, introducing a host of fantastical elements and a compelling portrayal of Davy Jones and his crew, without losing its grip on reality or the charm of the original.

The movie’s 80-minute climax, featuring Captain Jack Sparrow’s epic showdown with Davy Jones, is unforgettable.

Johnny Depp’s performance as Jack is as charismatic as ever.

The ‘Curse of the Black’ subplot adds depth and suspense, making ‘Caribbean: Dead Mans Chest’ a worthy runner up in the ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ movie series.

Top Spot: The Curse of the Black Pearl


You’ll find no contest in ranking ‘The Curse of the Black Pearl’ as the top movie in the ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ series.

It’s the pirate adventure that launched the legendary franchise, setting an unparalleled standard with its rip-roaring entertainment, coherent storytelling, and memorable humor.

Sparrow and Barbossa shine in this tale, placing ‘Caribbean: The Curse’ firmly in the top spot: the curse of the black pearl.


So, you’ve navigated the choppy waters of the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise. Surprisingly, the original ‘Curse of the Black Pearl’ still holds the treasure chest of top spot, setting the bar high for its sequels.

It’s interesting to note that, despite its lukewarm reception, ‘On Stranger Tides’ actually raked in over $1 billion worldwide. Guess it’s proof that not all that glitters is gold.

Here’s to hoping future sequels can recapture the magic of the original.

Leave a Comment